Skip to content

 
 

Meet the Moderators

Meet the moderators of these forums

Meet them all

Meet the Experts

Meet the experts in these forums

Community

Got something to say?

Got something to say?

You are in... Forums > General > Your cars > READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Go to most recent reply

kubrick

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 1541

kubrick says:

READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

 Some imaginary scenarios appear almost too perfect. Like the most perfect bubble, shining in mother of pearl’s delicate hues, just waiting to burst the instant you try touching it.
Turning an imagined perfect moment into a reality can only lead to disappointment. Either that, or this is just a very popular excuse on behalf of the dominion of mediocrity that shapes... almost everything.

But imagine yourself driving by Italy’s Lago di Garda. The pleasabt, warm temperatures; the lush green trees lining the Gardesana, this textbook concoction of grand vistas, elegant curves and beautiful villages, some of which are slightly dilapidated in that peacocky way only the Italians seem to be getting away with.

This is a road that, under most circumstances, should make for a delightful drive behind the wheel of even the most humble of motorcars. Naturally, one’s imagination, greedy as ever, is quick to provide somewhat more illustrious fantasies, as if to highlight the disappointment of one’s present. But the truth of the matter is: this piece of tarmac is begging for the right kind of car. Not necessarily for want of power or performance, but because this landscape deserves a machine that’s not left ashamed by nature’s lushness. Open-top motoring it has to be then, preferably of a mature age. Traffic levels as well as Italy’s new-found ambitions to enforce speed limits mean outright speed would actually be counterproductive. I’m therefore after cruising abilities (if not quite waftability), accompanied by good looks and an agreeable engine note. The ideal Gardesana motor would hence be a compact sixties convertible, and not necessarily the sportiest of the breed.

Which leads me straight to one of my all-time aesthetic favourites. The Mercedes W113, the Pagoda. I like to refer to it as the perfect woman’s car, and not in the sense some might want to describe a pink Nissan Micra CC. It’s the utter lack of aggression and its unpretentious, yet graceful stance that makes it the ideal vehicle for those more interested in class, rather than brash, loud exhibitionism - which tend to be of the fairer sex. Paul Bracq’s styling of the Pagoda lends it a mature and subtle quality that’s, in some regards, the opposite of the more extreme roadsters of the sixties. Does this mean a bloke can only drive it with a paper bag over his head? Most certainly not. A woman’s car made up of these characteristics would only repel the most blinkered of brutes.

In a case of extreme good luck, the beauty of Northern Italy and the epitome of elegant, Franco-German motoring were at my feet one sunny October afternoon - to create a most memorable driving experience. I’d consider myself privileged driving a Pagoda through Dortmund (or Milton Keynes, for that matter). But this combination of machinery and environment was one of those rare instances when the Automotive Gods aligned the stars.

After a simple, yet most pleasant pizza lunch I am handed the keys to a Mercedes-Benz 250 SL, W113, Pagoda convertible, complete with its original Italian owner’s manual in the passenger door pocket. In keeping with the Italian spirit of Sprezzatura, this Pagoda is neither run-down project car nor one of those ghostly concourse examples, which have been embalmed to a point where their age and very own history seem to have all but vanished. This particular Pagoda has been taken good care of, but it isn’t ashamed to show its age in certain areas. It also stands by its youthful folly of having additional fog lights.
And it even gets away with wearing whitewall tyres, which actually look superb in conjunction with its polished hub caps and the body’s metallic silver (with a hint of light blue) paint.

Attached images:

  1. DSC01616  
  2. DSC01722  

Reply to this Topic 

 
kubrick

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 1541

kubrick says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

 Having taken a seat, one cannot help but immediately fall in love with the Benz’ cockpit. This is a dashboard very far removed from sober German austerity, though it does stop short of overwhelming with glitz. And, quite in contrast to today, all that glitters is solid, tactile quality - no matter if plastic buttons, wood inserts or metal levers: this machine has clearly been engineered and built to last. And the “honesty” of the materials is simply a joy to behold; no imitation this or faux that - what you see is what you get. This ethos is far removed from the prevailing sense of high-class fakery that dominates car styling today and is best appreciated with hindsight. The fact that all these components (even the very pretty instruments) were in fact mass market products is almost eye-watering. To a simple - or, one could say: mechanical - man such as myself it is a relief when quality is making itself apparent in such obvious terms.
The seats are pure sixties Mercedes-Benz, too: the cushioning is rather tough, yet the entire seat feels somewhat floating. That this car’s purpose isn’t to chase after high speed turns is becoming very clear indeed: if one were foolish enough to attempt any such puerility, he (or she) would immediately slide off the - generously proportioned - seat. But the seats are merely one of a number of clear indications that this is not a sports car. Anyone who thinks a steering wheel the size of the Queen Elizabeth’s (the ship, mind you) is appropriate for challenging lap time records is clearly mistaken. And sitting in the wrong car.

The starting procedure, on the other hand, could be seen as an exercise in dashing manfulness: pushing the manual choke awakens the straight six engine with an athletic growl. After that, the Pagoda’s aural qualities remain civilised and subdued right up to about 3.000 RPM, when the engine refuses to conceal its superior design anymore and uses any tall wall or steep cliff by the wayside as a resonating body. The resulting sound is pleasant and emphatic, rather than just loud - it certainly won’t cause any avalanches, which would hardly be in keeping with the overall character of the car.

Attached images:

  1. DSC01617  
  2. DSC01626  

Reply to this Topic 

kubrick

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 1541

kubrick says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

 Yet this is where the SL’s brief flirtation with machismo ends. It may sound grunty (in a refined manner), but the straight six isn’t particularly powerful. Which is just as well, because if it was, it would have to fight a very hard and bloody battle with both the steering and, particularly, the gearbox. Mercedes-Benz’ reputation for perfectionism was probably much better deserved in the Pagoda’s days, which makes the company’s legendary inaptitude at constructing a decent manual gearbox all the more perplexing. The combination of long throw and notchy shift action makes it appear like one of Alec Issigonis’ concoctions aimed at keeping the (idiot) driver alert. In this instance, that means it’s relatively hard to keep the car flowing progressively - at least without a lot of experience - and successfully prevents the actual driving from becoming too engaging. Which must also be the reasoning behind the steering, which, apart from the gargantuan steering wheel itself, isn’t just indirect in typical sixties style, but also rather vague. On the upside it must be noted that the white bakelite is considerably grippier than expected, and much more so than a wooden steering wheel.

So is there a whiff of disappointment in that Italian autumnal breeze, that, even in October, just refuses to be chilly? Not at all. These weaknesses are perfectly in keeping with the attributes I’d associated with the Pagoda for so long, meaning I see them more as character traits, rather than failings. This Mercedes is the definition of a boulevardier, an unruffled, calm, pleasant motor, that simply cannot be bothered to be hurled along challenging b-roads. To me the lack of sharpness is mainly aimed at teaching the uninitiated what the Pagoda is all about. And, after all, Mercedes-Benz has a reputation for building some very fine automatic transmissions.

Yes, the gearbox indeed does its best to spoil the experience, but that isn’t nearly enough. Not with as pleasant an engine, not when the air is as warm and the view across the dashboard, the bonnet and the road as gorgeous as this.

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Attached images:

  1. DSC01673  

Reply to this Topic 

bertandnairobi

Joined:

Feb 07

Posts: 4493

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

I have to leave my desk right now but I am looking forward to reading this. Fine photos!

Reply to this Topic 

Sam the Eagle

Joined:

Oct 06

Posts: 3041

Online

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Great piece, Kubrick. I enjoyed reading it.

 

 

Hell is other people.

Reply to this Topic 

seant

Joined:

Feb 09

Posts: 1793

Online

seant says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Kubrick. A very fine review and, speaking as someone who cruised beside Lake Garda the month before you, accompanied by the diesel clatter of a Fiat Ducato, yours is an object exercise in how it should be done. That dashboard view is such a delight. Strangely, if Mercedes had to fit a manual to the Pagoda, I feel that a column shift would have been more appropriate. Don’t laugh - a good column shift, as in large Peugeots of the past, was actually very pleasant to use, with your hands barely leaving the wheel, but they lost out to the sporty pretensions of the stick shift. And yes, those narrow band whitewalls do suit it.

Reply to this Topic 

kubrick

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 1541

kubrick says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

 Thank you for the kind words!

SeanT, I don't have any column shift experience whatsoever, but it couldn't possibly be any worse than the Merc's stick shift. In German, there's a rather neat term to describe its shift action: it's called the Bonanza effect. And apparently those dedicated boffins at Untertürkheim didn't manage to overcome this in decades.

During my stay in Italy I actually read Octane's anniversary issue, which included a trip through France in an SM. I guess it's only a matter of time before you'll enjoy the beauty of Southern Europe while operating what must still be among the prettiest gear sticks in automotive history, isn't it?

Reply to this Topic 

Sam the Eagle

Joined:

Oct 06

Posts: 3041

Online

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Forgot to ask: were the seats covered in M-B Tex or leather?

 

 

Hell is other people.

Reply to this Topic 

seant

Joined:

Feb 09

Posts: 1793

Online

seant says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Kubrick. In a previous body colour, my SM knows those roads quite well, and I certainly hope to return in it sometime.  It is indeed a pretty stick, but I have to admit that it hides a slightly shameful secret.  The wand is a graceful piece of chromed steel, but the lower part of the knob is, in fact, vacuum metalised plastic.  I'm sure you wouldn't find that on the Mercedes!

Reply to this Topic 

kubrick

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 1541

kubrick says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

 Sam, I believe it was leather, though the seats were in suspiciously good condition - they were probably re-upholstered at some point.

SeanT, you're quite right, this breed of Mercedes was too proud to hide any dark secrets. On the other hand, an R107 SL's cabin is visually vandalised if the original owner chose the manual option (for some absurd reason). The mechanics underneath it were probably a thing of beauty, but those plastic sacks were just awful to look at.

Reply to this Topic 

seant

Joined:

Feb 09

Posts: 1793

Online

seant says:

Re: READER REVIEW: Mercedes-Benz 250 SL (W113)

Looking at that wonderful steering wheel (in fact the old-school cliche ‘helm’ is more apt for once) I’m struck by the psychology of the horn ring. Today’s horn controls are near-invisible, reflecting the fact that they are there as a last resort. Although you rightly point out, Kubrick, that the SL is a car that you don’t fling around, the horn ring does suggest a past age when you made shameless progress, thumb caressing the chrome to imperiously usher lesser mortals in their wheezing saloons to the side of the road as you breezed past.

Reply to this Topic 

12Next>>

Post a message in Your cars

Fields marked with an asterisk * are required

To post a reply to this topic, please Log In.

Most popular