Skip to content

 
 

Meet the Moderators

Meet the moderators of these forums

Meet them all

Meet the Experts

Meet the experts in these forums

Community

Got something to say?

Got something to say?

You are in... Forums > General > General motoring > Motoring issues > Speed Limited

Go to most recent reply

Batty

Joined:

Mar 08

Posts: 4885

Batty says:

Speed Limited

Speed Limited.
To the dedicated readers of the forum (aside from lokinen and myself, are there any others left?), I would like to gather some opinions. Why are we still speed limited on our motorways? In Australia, the limit is still the same 110 kph as it was when my parents drove me around as a small child over 30 years ago. Why is this still applied even though technology has advanced in both road maintenance and signage, not to mention the absolutely enormous gains in vehicle safety over the same period? Surely, the increase in traffic has been offset by these advances? Why can’t the speed limit be variable dependant on traffic and conditions anyway? Many motorways are taxed, so at any one time one can be almost certain as to the traffic density, even those that aren’t have some sort of registering network to determine vehicle speed over distance for infringements. All of this allows for a variable speed network of motorways at no extra cost. Surely the experiment is worth pursuing for even a short period to at least prove, or disprove bias and statistics. I, for one would be pleased to have a reduced limit in dense traffic in poor conditions, to balance an empty motorway run in good conditions at 3 am at say 180 or 190 kph.
What do you think?
 

Ha,ha,ha,ha,ha.

Reply to this Topic 

 
supercarrambler

Joined:

Jun 08

Posts: 1112

Re: Speed Limited

i hate myself too, I spent ages rebuilding my Y10 Turbo and on it's maiden voyage I left the sump bolt loose.

Simplify and add lightness.

Reply to this Topic 

Batty

Joined:

Mar 08

Posts: 4885

Batty says:

Re: Speed Limited

Despite the seething jealousy, that is truly unfortunate my friend. Please tell me you were taking it easy and noticed quickly!

Ha,ha,ha,ha,ha.

Reply to this Topic 

supercarrambler

Joined:

Jun 08

Posts: 1112

Re: Speed Limited

no and no, my friend spotted a trail of oil on his drive way and basically followed it to my house, I never took notice on the Star Trek style dash as it suffered the normal italian gremlins.

As you can guess I picked up bit of a knock !

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Simplify and add lightness.

Reply to this Topic 

livc44411

Joined:

Apr 08

Posts: 2362

livc44411 says:

Re: Speed Limited

Whats next then? You going to try again rebuilding it?

-Focus RS,Megane RS,you gotta love 'em-

Reply to this Topic 

pete917

Joined:

Jan 09

Posts: 29

pete917 says:

Re: Speed Limited

I think speed in the right conditions in the right car is fine.  Germany's autobahn's are a great example where speed seems to work fine.  Todays cars can stop more quickly and are much more stable at high speeds, yet we still have the same speed limits and the highways code still talks about the same old stopping distances.  The big land rovers and range rovers struggle to match these distances, but fast cars, or cars that are designed to go fast, stop within these distances with ease.

As a result I go to the track with my car every once and a while and let it all out !

Reply to this Topic 

ga41

Joined:

Apr 07

Posts: 2942

ga41 says:

Re: Speed Limited

That's great if there are tracks you can go to. But here for example there are none..

Anyway as you say modern cars are much improved in every aspect than the cars that were around at the time those speed limits were created but think this. In Cyprus the max speed limit on the highway is 100kph but everyone regularly go at 120-140kph. And that includes good drivers, bad drivers, first time drivers, grannies and grandpas, lorries, bangers etc etc. The few people with performance cars usualy blast by them at 180+. Now imagine if they raised the speed limit to 130kph. Everyone would still go about 30-40 over the limit which makes it 170-180! And the power mad people? Now they would go at 240-250... Now tell me how that wouldnt cause more accidents! (at least here anyway).

- http://www.freerice.com/ For each answer you get right, they will donate 10 grains of rice to the United Nations World Food Program -

Reply to this Topic 

pete917

Joined:

Jan 09

Posts: 29

pete917 says:

Re: Speed Limited

you raise a good point ga41.  Germany seem to have mastered it on their autobahns, so I guess it can work sometimes.

 

I am luicky though I only live a few mins away from Brands Hatch

Reply to this Topic 

ga41

Joined:

Apr 07

Posts: 2942

ga41 says:

Re: Speed Limited

pete917 said:

you raise a good point ga41.  Germany seem to have mastered it on their autobahns, so I guess it can work sometimes.

 

I am luicky though I only live a few mins away from Brands Hatch


Of course it can work but there are so many factors to take into account. A solution that works in the UK might not necessarily work for Cyprus for example. Out here as i;ve said before the main problem is poor road manners and a general lack of adequate training before you're allowed to hit the streets. The driver's attitude if you will.

Now i wont lie and say i dont drive aggressively or speed. I do drive quite aggressively and sometimes i do break the speed limit but i ALWAYS follow the rules of the road! (except for that speed part.. ) I always keep the correct lane, stop where i'm supposed to, always indicate if im going to turn and pretty much do everything any NORMAL driver is required to do. But the s**t i see on the road every day just makes me furious. People talking on the phone and driving with one hand while taking their kids to school, people not checking their mirrors or people who display piss poor lane disciple, people who dont even stop at freaking stop signs! And then when they cut you off and you honk at them they give you attitude on top! What they fail to realise is that by just obeying the law everyone wouldnt have to double check on what the other driver is going to surprise them by doing and just get to where they wanna go much faster!

Anyway, the common Cypriot driver is a bloody idiot. And then when kids spend all their childhood watching their bloody idiot mom and dad drive like a bloody idiot. Then what kind of driver will they grow up to be? Yes, a bloody idiot one.

- http://www.freerice.com/ For each answer you get right, they will donate 10 grains of rice to the United Nations World Food Program -

Reply to this Topic 

JohnnyBimmer

Joined:

Jan 08

Posts: 4364

JohnnyBimmer says:

Re: Speed Limited

Spain Puts UK To Shame On Road Deaths

Figures released by Spain's show a drop of 1/5th in road fatalities. 2,182 were killed in 2008, some 559 fewer than the previous year. Despite Spain having a similar number of vehicles on the road as the UK, the most recent fatality figure in the UK was 2,946, a damning indictment of failing UK road safety policy. Trends over the past 15 years have seen Spain more than halve their annual fatality figure despite rapid traffic growth whilst the UK have only seen a reduction of around 20%.

So, how can Spains success teach the UK's road safety establishment to learn from their experience?

ABD spokesman Nigel Humphries explains: "Spain, like the UK will have benefited from the dramatic improvement in car design. Without this it is likely UK casualties would have risen, road safety policy here can take little credit for our miserable achievement. Spain, unlike the UK has invested greatly in engineering, ironing out blackspots, realigning and junctions, bypassing towns and villages and replacing the most dangerous roads with dual carriageways. They have also relied on good old fashioned policing. 'Trafico' officers can often be seen watching the roads and pulling up suspicious looking vehicles or drivers. What they have not done is to flood the country with speed cameras, nor does there seem to be a great emphasis on speed enforcement. Here in the UK road safety policy has concentrated almost solely on cameras and enforcement and people are still dying."

ABD Chairman Brian Gregory commented: "The UK road safety chiefs need to learn and learn fast that their policies are failing. We need a return to good old fashioned policing and investment in engineering. How many more need to die before they wake up?"

(Source. Association of British Motorists. 19/02/09  http://www.abd.org.uk/

Reply to this Topic 

Batty

Joined:

Mar 08

Posts: 4885

Batty says:

Re: Speed Limited

A very interesting article Johhny here's an excerpt of  one taken from wheels ( www.wheelsmag.com.au ) a local magazine.

Removing the open road speed limit on remote highways in the Northern Territory has led to a disastrous increase in road deaths and a sharp upward trend in the toll.

In 2007, the first year of the reduction of the open road limit to 130km/h, the NT road toll increased from 42 (in 2006) to 58, up an alarming 38 percent.

Last year, the bad news continued with the death toll on NT roads increasing again, from 58 (in 2007) to 75, a hike of 29.3 percent.

The 2008 NT road toll of 75 is the worst since 1987.

During the first two-year period of the 130km/h limit, there was an increase of 33 road deaths - or more than 78 percent - says the National Motorists Association of Australia (NMAA).

Up until the 130km/h speed limit was introduced in the Territory on January 1, 2007, against great opposition from road safety experts, the NT road toll was trending downwards.

The open road limit was dumped by a cynical and soft NT Labor Government following a concerted campaign by the usual limelight junkies from down south, and an investigation by a road safety taskforce.

The open road limit was sensible in the NT with its long, straight roads and real prospects of driver boredom and fatigue. Territorians typically travel more kilometres annually than their southern counterparts.

The taskforce had found that 48 percent of deaths were alcohol related. The government acknowledged that drink driving, running red lights and seatbelt offences were the major safety concerns in the NT, and then it went about ignoring its own advice and applying the highway speed limits - 110 on all but the four main highways, which have a 130 km/h limit.

The carnage on the NT roads over the past two calendar years contrasts with the rest of the nation where death trends are largely down.
A general downward trend in road deaths is understandable given the emergence of life-saving features like stability control and airbags/side curtains on modern motor vehicles.

Official figures released in its annual reports by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau show that in 2008 every state and territory except the NT recorded a decrease in road fatalities (the ACT recorded the same numbers as in 2007 - 14).

The NMAA questions how much effort NT authorities put into diagnosing the causes of deaths on the Territory's roads.

"You can't manage what you don't measure," said Gavin Goeldner, a spokesman for the NMAA.

The association is urging the NT government to urgently release detailed statistics regarding the attributed causes of the 2007 and 2008 fatalities, and to highlight black spot regions, so that this alarming trend can be understood and reversed.

The NMAA has always opposed the move to lower speed limits for fear of increased fatigue related crashes.  

So there is also proof, recently of the negative impact of speed limits on certain roadways. 

BUT....

We, all of us ALLOW it to happen. I wonder if we made a unanimous gesture of protest by driving at half the posted speed limit (which is entirely legal) in a coordinated manner along highways would it change anything? Imagine the social upheaval if we all obeyed the law? Only on highways mind, that is where the problem lies. Imagine the congestion and the daily revenue loss!

Any takers?

Ha,ha,ha,ha,ha.

Reply to this Topic 

Post a message in Motoring issues

Fields marked with an asterisk * are required

To post a reply to this topic, please Log In.

Most popular