Skip to content

 
 

Meet the Moderators

Meet the moderators of these forums

Meet them all

Meet the Experts

Meet the experts in these forums

Community

Got something to say?

Got something to say?

You are in... Forums > General > Technology and engineering > Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

Go to most recent reply

TimPollard

Joined:

Sep 06

Posts: 505

TimPollard says:

Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

Hi all. We're planning a piece in the next issue of CAR Magazine looking at the new Porsche Boxster coming in 2012. I'm really keen to use some feedback from readers - your ideas on what Porsche should do to improve it. Some fresh thinking from the ever-erudite CAR forum fanbase. Should it be repositioned? Smaller? Bigger? Simpler? Lighter? Electric? Scrapped altogether? Your comments will feature in the November issue, so fire away.

Afraid we're on a tight turnaround and need your feedback in the next 24 hours! Please have a ponder and comment away...

[This Topic has been modified by the Author]

Reply to this Topic 

 
CAR magazine

Joined:

Nov 07

Posts: 1111

CAR magazine says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche improve it?

......

Reply to this Topic 

Sam the Eagle

Joined:

Oct 06

Posts: 3042

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche improve it?

front and rear are difficult to tell apart and have had me confused for too long. Please Porsche make the necessary changes before some serious accident occurs...

 

 

 

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Hell is other people.

Reply to this Topic 

Skavold

Joined:

Oct 09

Posts: 48

Skavold says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche improve it?

I'm afraid that I don't have firsthand experience with the Boxster, but I don't think it would hurt making it  (and the Cayman) more focused than what it is today. Make it lighter, sexier and ultimately the real small and sporty alternative to the 911.

Also; please give it a design of its own! Don't fall into the classic Porsche trap of making everything look as 911-ish as humanly possible. Make it stand out!

 

_____________

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

-- I haven't owned an Alfa Romeo ... yet --

Reply to this Topic 

taaudi

Joined:

Oct 09

Posts: 40

taaudi says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

" Break the mould.... let it stand out in its own right, instead of it being too bland. Re-design the whole thing as if you haven't got a model to work from!"

Reply to this Topic 

JohnSpencer

Joined:

Jan 07

Posts: 206

JohnSpencer says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

 

I bought an old 986 Boxster a few months ago in preference to a Lotus Elise. Like many people I did this because the Boxster doesn’t seeth with anger when you drive in traffic, doesn’t leak from its roof, and doesn’t hurt to get into. Or out of.

I see the Boxster as car for people who love driving, but have to drive every day, in all weathers, in all traffic. It’s happy to burble along at tickover in top gear, but comes alive as soon as you change down a few gears and point it at a corner.

I’m sure Georg Kacher has already told us in Car Magazine that the next Boxster is moving upmarket to make way for a budget Boxster, which leaves me to fear that the next Boxster  will be larger and heavier. Porsche will make it more powerful to compensate, such that its performance stats are ever so slightly better than the current car, but still just below 911 territory. It will be objectively better in so many ways, but back-to-back with an early Boxster it will feel too civilised, too much of a cruiser, too much like an Audi. The rumoured sub-baby-Boxster-junior will be a better proposition, but hampered by low power, a heavy cost-saving all-steel body and component-sharing with unmentionable parts of the VW empire.

What Porsche should do:

(1)  Make the Boxster visually distinctive. The front end of the first Boxster looked like a 911 because it was the front end of a 911. Times are better now so there’s no reason for quite that level or parts sharing.

 (2) Keep the weight down. A more upmarket Boxster could surely have lots of composite or aluminium components. This also might be a cheaper way of keeping emissions down than a hybrid system.

 (3) Keep the suspension supple. Leave the medieval-torture sport suspension on the options list.

 (4) Also leave the 19” wheels on the options list. The Boxster should be compact and lithe and not suffer distended arches stretched over bling rims.

(5) Keep the manual gearbox. Don’t make it PDK only.

(6) Don’t give it a folding metal roof. Keep the regular soft top.

(7) … er, that’s all I can think of for now.

 

 

Reply to this Topic 

gtrslngr

Joined:

Nov 09

Posts: 3079

gtrslngr says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

#1) Shrink it !

#2) Offer it with a 4 cylinder version of the flat six

#3) Make the above version a good bargain

#4) Get some stones , admit the Boxster/Cayman are better handling cars than the 911 in spite of all the electronics and engineering will ever be and stuff the 911 / GT3 and the Turbo motor in the back of the Boxster/Cayman in  upper range models, creating the ultimate usable SuperCar

#5) Make it so somebody over 6' can actually fit in the ( bleep) thing .

 

Which is to say ; The Boxster/Cayman is a fantastic , versatile  platform for Porsche to go in many directions with along with creating a World Beating GT for racing . Keeping the 911 in the line up for the Die Hards etc.   

Rock On - Drive On - Remain Calm - and Carry On

Reply to this Topic 

lokinen

Joined:

Aug 06

Posts: 2262

lokinen says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

Have never been a great fan of the Boxster, for me it's image is too soft . I've noticed they appeal to women far more than the 911 does, in fact the 911 seems not to appeal to women at all. Also i've known non petrol head guys to buy them which kind of says it all really. When i finally got to go out in one though, i was blown away. The driver didn't give it the full beans by any means but the sheer quality of the thing was superb.Then my temporary lodger bought an old W plate one and it was like brand new still. Very impressive.For me they need to keep the quality and toughen up the rear end styling, banishing the pointy turd look. I think its about time that real life 25MPG was attainable from at least one version of the car during urban driving.

Beep Beep

Reply to this Topic 

richfish

Joined:

Aug 06

Posts: 3

richfish says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

 I know it's going to go upmarket and the VW/Audi 4 cylinder thing will take its place but to improve the Boxster it needs to become more Elise-like whilst retaining the Porsche qualities. I had the privilege to drive a friend's early Boxster S a few years back and it was great. Responsive engine and a hewn-from-solid-billet feeling about the whole thing. I would agree with others about the change in styling to distance it from the 911 but what is underneath is more important. I had hoped the Cayman would be a sub-Boxster stripped out special but that went further upmarket. The next Boxster needs to be an enthusiasts's Porsche that won't appeal to poseurs. Keep it simple with a sub 3 litre engine, manual 'box and one suspension setting. Dump the pointless electrics and have manual fabric roof, manual seats even ditch electric windows. Above all, keep the weight down. A 1000-1100kg target should be what Porsche aims for. Some clever aluminium or composites should make this achievable. 

I'll never be able to afford one but at least if they make it like this I won't be assuming what us petrolheads normally assume when we see a big wheeled blinged up Boxster slowly moving along with its roof up accompanied by a generous whiff of hair products.

Reply to this Topic 

gtrslngr

Joined:

Nov 09

Posts: 3079

gtrslngr says:

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

lokinen ; Drive a Ruf version of the Boxter/Cayman . You'll be blown away by how under powered that chassis is in all its current Porsche guises .  

Rock On - Drive On - Remain Calm - and Carry On

Reply to this Topic 

Sam the Eagle

Joined:

Oct 06

Posts: 3042

Re: Porsche Boxster: what should Porsche do to improve it?

does it actually need more power? For real world, every day use, or even for the track (but it's not really designed for the race track anyway)? I don't think so.

 

 

 

 

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Hell is other people.

Reply to this Topic 

12Next>>

Post a message in Technology and engineering

Fields marked with an asterisk * are required

To post a reply to this topic, please Log In.

Most popular