Skip to content

 
 

CAR Reviews

Click Thumbnails to Enlarge

Statistics

Need to know

CAR's rating

Rated 3 out of 53

Handling

Rated 3 out of 53

Performance

Rated 3 out of 53

Usability

Rated 4 out of 54

Feelgood factor

Rated 4 out of 54

Readers' rating

Rated 2.5 out of 52.5

Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

By Anthony ffrench-Constant

First Drives

14 June 2012 10:38

I drove the latest Audi Q3 recently. And it got me thinking.

I’ve heard of compassion fatigue - whereby an endless succession of charities make such relentless Tele- and radiothon-sponsored demands on the public purse that, eventually, the well indulges in a little covert self-sealing even if not strictly dry - but am now wondering whether we might be on the verge of an entirely new phenomenon which, for the purposes of this piece, I shall dub Quality Fatigue.

Audi: can we have too much quality?

One major pitfall of this job is the potential to start regarding the really quite exceptional as commonplace. Indeed, I haven’t forgotten a recent group outing hallmarked by one esteemed staff member’s pre-test adjudication: ‘We’re bored of Audis’ he said.

Now that’s an odd position to reach… And makes me wonder if the public have begun to feel the same way?

Audi Q3: the styling

Walter da Silva’s Big Grille, of which I still cannot approve, may have done a whisker too much to bring family-arity to the range’s road presence, but they certainly don’t all drive the same.

A quarter mile duration revisit of the A5 Sportback the other day (sorry; it was all I could stomach), allegedly re-fettled after the gentle roasting the ride quality received at launch, suggests that whoever eased off on the springs and dampers tightened everything right back up the moment no one was looking.

Audi Q3: the review bit

The latest 2012 Audi Q3, by contrast, is a very decent, if hardly memorable drive. What is memorable is the growing signs that, faced with an increasingly monstrous bill for champagne as new models grease down the slipway with a frequency that would tax even a Radio 5 Live tennis commentator, the company seems hard pushed to differentiate each new interior from the next.

In this case, the new constitutes little save – admittedly beautifully detailed - surround strip lighting to the front door loudspeakers and, erm, the centre console cupholders.

But let’s face it; to date, anyone who goes out to buy an Audi does it, to some extent, precisely because the average model interior is a seriously wholesome nugget of iron-clad design, bullet-proof build quality, intuitive ergonomics and the visual equivalent of hot chocolate with marshmallows, whipped cream and a Flake on top.

Mr and Mrs Punter have already signed up for that stock Audi interior, then, all they’re doing upon the prising open of the purse is selecting the size and shape of vehicle within which they receive it.

Audi and quality fatigue

So I am, I must confess, more than somewhat embarrassed by the fact that this remains my abiding memory of a car I lived with for a week, and many would kill to afford. Quality fatigue? Or have I simply allowed my senses to become submerged beneath the treacherous, yet strangely selective, Audi Swamp of Sameness?

Odd, because I don’t seem to suffer the same issues with Mercedes and, largely thanks to the Wisconsin Wunderkind (and the, ahem, road manners of all too many owners), don’t actually covet enough of the BMW model range to find myself over-concerned…

Verdict

Mental note, then, to try harder to differentiate 'twixt Audis on your behalf in the future. However, short of sending every car out with Miss Whiplash primed and ready in the back, I’m not sure what the company can actually do to make the experience more memorable. Except, of course, rein right back in on the new model launch frequency…

And that, undoubtedly, falls into the Fat Chance category.

 

1

Rate this article...

Average rating: Rated 2.5 out of 52.5 (31 votes)

Discuss this

Add your comment

Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

Subject

Your comment

By submitting your comment, you agree to adhere to the CAR Magazine website Terms and Conditions

Cancel

 

jacomoseven

reward badge

jacomoseven says

RE: Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

Disappointing, Mr ff. I hoped you would have given this risible little hatchback a thorough kicking, pausing only to allow a few of us a go.

 

@ rickerby, nice comparison, although the brown one reminds me of an Austin Maestro - with it's owners equally oblivious to its mediocrity.

15 June 2012 23:01

 

hangtime10

hangtime10 says

RE: Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

@MG5Sport

So your everyday driving consists of high speed cornering, hard braking and driving like you're in Le Mans? Is that the kind of driving you do?

I say "well", because yes I admit that I go around corners above the posted limits (5 - 10 over) but at those speeds Audi's are ok. If I were to go to the track on a regular basis, I'd definitely want something more engaging. But just driving to and from work, in traffic or just above the speed limits. IMO Audi's would be ok.

It's great that we can read what critics say about Audi's as they test the cars at their limits. But how many of us actually drop the clutch at 6K rpms from a stop light?

15 June 2012 14:25

 

ronwhite

reward badge

ronwhite says

RE: Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

 Gregg218's Dad was s right, and Audi have built their USP on this important principle. Combine this with an instantly identifiable grille, a family style (ie they all look much the same) and brilliant promotion, and Audi has captured the middle class market. Object lesson. 

14 June 2012 21:46

 

JohnnyD

reward badge

JohnnyD says

RE: Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

It's just fatigue in general with the bewildering amount of cars the German makers are foisting on the buying public. Where once you sit up with interest at a new Audi, BMW or MB now you just glaze over unless its a R8, i8 or SLS.

 

@rickerby - longer waiting list for Q3 than Evoque? Are you sure?? Sorry to doubt you but I find that really hard to believe.

14 June 2012 21:19

 

rickerby

reward badge

rickerby says

RE: Audi Q3 (2012) CAR review

Audi sort of remind me of Ford UK circa late 1970s. Everyone seems to hate them, yet everyone seems to be buying them. The waiting list for the Q3 eclipses even that of the Evoque. Its the British disease. Success is something to discourage at all costs!

14 June 2012 17:50

Become a CAR contributor

Upload stories, photos or videos direct to the site, or email newsdesk@carmagazine.co.uk.

Alternatively, call 01733 468 485 (+ 44 1733 468 485)

CAR magazine June issue 611
Untitled Document

Become a CAR contributor

Seen a secret new car, fabulous exotic or have news we should publish? Then get in touch now.