Skip to content
BMW models, news & reviews
4
Handling
Performance
3
Usability
Feelgood factor
Readers' rating
2.5
By Tim Pollard
First Drives
06 January 2011 12:02
BMW’s X3 has long been the runt of the Munich litter. The last X3 was seemingly made of less sturdy stuff than other BM models and didn’t drive as sharply either. But it hopes to reverse all that with the new F25-codename X3.
It still looks like a shrunken X5, but you’re less likely to confuse the two now thanks to peculiarly squared-off headlamps and a strong character line scalloped in the side flanks. This one’s built alongside BMW’s big seven-seater SUV at the Spartanburg factory in the USA, not the Magna facility in Graz, Austria. Bodes well for a jump in quality to match the tight-fit we expect from BM.
We’ve just driven the likely best seller, the X3 xDrive20d, expected to hog 80% of UK sales. On paper, it seems all the X3 you’ll ever need. Its 2.0-litre aluminium four-cylinder achieves 181bhp and 280lb ft from 1750-2750rpm.
The figures speak for themselves: the 2.0d will scuttle to 62mph in 8.5sec and on to 130mph on the autobahn. But the rather more important figures of 147g/km and 50.4mpg are achieved thanks to standard stop-start and a new, leggy eight-speed ZF automatic gearbox.
The X3 is priced from £30,490, which is rather remarkably cheaper than the last X3. Further reason why the 2.0d is going to be popular in Britain: it comes with leather upholstery and twin-zone climate control as standard.
We tested a remarkably boggo xDrive20d with a six-speed manual 'box. Two testers found the lever positioned too far back and it's neither a quick nor a slick change. On balance, we'd recommend picking that eight-speed auto, which also knocks a couple of digits off the carbon emissions.
Performance is brisk enough, but you have to rev the 2.0 D to match those performance claims, and we found the engine a tad loud.
Our car was fitted with winter tyres and we drove it in the snows of Christmas. Traction was peerless, as you’d expect, and the fully electric power steering is as meaty as you'd expect from a BMW SUV. This is a very competent 4x4.
Family-spirited owners will enjoy decent practicality in the new X3. The boot is 550 litres with the rear seats in place, swelling to 1600 with them folded flat. It’s an easy boot to access and there’s plenty of room front and rear. As there should be - the new X3 is 80mm longer than before.
There’s plenty of optional equipment to spec your X3 just so. A 6.5in digital monitor is standard, but you can spec that up to 8.8in if you upgrade to the fancier sat-nav. Our car came with the smaller screen – rare for a press demonstrator – and proved that even more boggo X3s feel well up to scratch. One other road tester in the office found the 3-series-alike dashboard a bit too cheap, mind you.
A panoramic 360deg parking camera is available to help ease parking, while you can order three individual rear seats each of which stows independently, head-up displays (highly recommended) and online connectivity.
The X3 does the job you'd expect. While we're not sure about the looks and drove it mostly in severe winter weather, we still found a very practical, well equipped and comfortable mid-sized SUV.
It might be strangely lacking in some key BMW attributes, but we've a sneaking suspicion they might be resolved in other variants.
Add your comment
Sign in You must be signed in to submit a comment.
BMW X3 xDrive20d SE (2011) CAR review
Subject
Your comment
By submitting your comment, you agree to adhere to the CAR Magazine website Terms and Conditions
Cancel
You must be logged in to subscribe to a topic
Login or register now
grumpeyoleman says
RE: BMW X3 xDrive20d SE (2011) CAR review
Looks of the car?... well beauty is in the eye of the beholder is it not? Better than the old X3? Driving the car, so far (took delivery mid June 2011) has not been without its problems although these have been 'sorted' by an update/ re-coding of the software. Had been experiencing occasional stuuter from engine and then more alarmingly a 'rattle', not unlike an old Hackney cab on a cold morning. Dash display also did not react to aambient light conditions and occasionally did not show at all. All now fixed (I hope!). Fuel consumption on a motorway trip at a steady 60mph brought in 51mpg but this drops to about 40-42mpg at 70 mph. Not bad for a car of its size. Now my 8th BMW, bought my first one in 1988 - 3 series, and pleased with the car despite initial problems. Don't get brushed off with 'the diagnostic socket shows no recorded faults' as computerrs are actually not as clever as humans.
Looks of the car?... well beauty is in the eye of the beholder is it not? Better than the old X3?
Driving the car, so far (took delivery mid June 2011) has not been without its problems although these have been 'sorted' by an update/ re-coding of the software. Had been experiencing occasional stuuter from engine and then more alarmingly a 'rattle', not unlike an old Hackney cab on a cold morning. Dash display also did not react to aambient light conditions and occasionally did not show at all. All now fixed (I hope!).
Fuel consumption on a motorway trip at a steady 60mph brought in 51mpg but this drops to about 40-42mpg at 70 mph. Not bad for a car of its size.
Now my 8th BMW, bought my first one in 1988 - 3 series, and pleased with the car despite initial problems. Don't get brushed off with 'the diagnostic socket shows no recorded faults' as computerrs are actually not as clever as humans.
14 October 2011 13:01
aussiejon says
Honestly!! You people banging on about the "young" 5 series tourer! IT IS BORING AS HELL! (particularly the 520d). I have driven the 5 series 520d and nearly fell asleep. Yes, if you need an economical well equipped large estate the 520d is very good. Me? I have ordered a 3.0d X3 which has fab acceleration, torque AND economy, PLUS loads of room and a commanding driving position. To me that all adds up to FUN driving!
11 August 2011 20:29
oldgit66 says
Carmobster, thanks for the excuse to buy the X3. I agree the 5 Touring is a better car however I am moving from a very useful MPV, a Grand Scenic, with a lofty view and a lofty interior so a 5 Touring is a retrograde if posher alternative. Also, another reason to like the X3 is 4 wheel drive. I have had a situation on snowy journey that I thought a front drive vehicle would swallow easily. Driving through Northern Brittany I encountered a main route with packed snow and icy surfaces. The Grand Scenic had a hell of a job getting through it. A 5 Touring would have been in the ditch within a kilometre - many vehicles were. I surmise the X3 should be OK? Robinstp - re the auto box on the X3 - it's very good - seamless in fact but I just don't like autos so I ordered the X3 with a manual shift. I wouldn't say it's the best in class manual gear change but after nearly 50 years driving manuals I am reluctant to change.
Carmobster, thanks for the excuse to buy the X3. I agree the 5 Touring is a better car however I am moving from a very useful MPV, a Grand Scenic, with a lofty view and a lofty interior so a 5 Touring is a retrograde if posher alternative. Also, another reason to like the X3 is 4 wheel drive. I have had a situation on snowy journey that I thought a front drive vehicle would swallow easily. Driving through Northern Brittany I encountered a main route with packed snow and icy surfaces. The Grand Scenic had a hell of a job getting through it. A 5 Touring would have been in the ditch within a kilometre - many vehicles were. I surmise the X3 should be OK?
Robinstp - re the auto box on the X3 - it's very good - seamless in fact but I just don't like autos so I ordered the X3 with a manual shift. I wouldn't say it's the best in class manual gear change but after nearly 50 years driving manuals I am reluctant to change.
16 January 2011 18:18
robinstp says
I want to bring up a technical point here. In the last three to four years there has been a leap in transmissions. Gone is the 4 speed auto - which was never very good - and in came the better 5 speed (I am talking all cars not BMW at the moment) - this was then quickly superceeded by the 6 speed. And now BMW give us a bloody 8speed!!! I would like to ask what economical savings are there in have 8 changes instead of a properly focused 6?? If you care to read my blog in Forum on favourite routes and my journey through a piece of Russia in snow these last days - I did a test in Full Auto and manual alternative with the same box. The result was startling - 20% saving on the manual facility. Why? simple - the things starts in FIRST when in Auto - whereas I use 2nd in manual - it changes down to first when stopping - when in manual I leave it in 3rd and let it slip automatically to first which is does when actually stopping - then flick it to 2nd to start off again. So if you have 8 of these things playing a musical interlude during your journey - it MUST me consuming 10% more fuel than really neccessary. So why the emphasis on autoboxes with multiple change being tuned for your ease and comfort? Me things there is a smelly rat here. How about being able to make bigger profits - because Auto's always cost more than stick shift - logical - but the size of the charge is now well hidden as they dont offer you a manual option!!
I want to bring up a technical point here. In the last three to four years there has been a leap in transmissions. Gone is the 4 speed auto - which was never very good - and in came the better 5 speed (I am talking all cars not BMW at the moment) - this was then quickly superceeded by the 6 speed. And now BMW give us a bloody 8speed!!! I would like to ask what economical savings are there in have 8 changes instead of a properly focused 6?? If you care to read my blog in Forum on favourite routes and my journey through a piece of Russia in snow these last days - I did a test in Full Auto and manual alternative with the same box. The result was startling - 20% saving on the manual facility. Why? simple - the things starts in FIRST when in Auto - whereas I use 2nd in manual - it changes down to first when stopping - when in manual I leave it in 3rd and let it slip automatically to first which is does when actually stopping - then flick it to 2nd to start off again.
So if you have 8 of these things playing a musical interlude during your journey - it MUST me consuming 10% more fuel than really neccessary. So why the emphasis on autoboxes with multiple change being tuned for your ease and comfort? Me things there is a smelly rat here. How about being able to make bigger profits - because Auto's always cost more than stick shift - logical - but the size of the charge is now well hidden as they dont offer you a manual option!!
13 January 2011 13:27
carmobster says
Wait oldgit66! I have just seen a reason why you should buy an X3! It is called the Audi Q5 Hybrid. It is 8,000 pounds more than the Q5 hybrid. It also warms the globe faster with 160g/km compared to BMW's 149 g/km. And while it's faster than the BMW it's useless because why should you want to go faster in a dynamically inferior car than say a A4 or an 3 series where it is losely based on. If you want fast buy an 335i touring or S4 Avant. It is also 100 kg lighter, while being larger and offers more space. See! I found an reason to buy a X3. But, it's still inferior to a similarly priced 520d Touring.........
Wait oldgit66! I have just seen a reason why you should buy an X3! It is called the Audi Q5 Hybrid.
It is 8,000 pounds more than the Q5 hybrid. It also warms the globe faster with 160g/km compared to BMW's 149 g/km. And while it's faster than the BMW it's useless because why should you want to go faster in a dynamically inferior car than say a A4 or an 3 series where it is losely based on. If you want fast buy an 335i touring or S4 Avant.
It is also 100 kg lighter, while being larger and offers more space.
See! I found an reason to buy a X3. But, it's still inferior to a similarly priced 520d Touring.........
13 January 2011 13:12
Upload stories, photos or videos direct to the site, or email newsdesk@carmagazine.co.uk.
Alternatively, call 01733 468 485 (+ 44 1733 468 485)
Seen a secret new car, fabulous exotic or have news we should publish? Then get in touch now.