Skip to content
Nissan models, news & reviews
4
Handling
Performance
3
Usability
Feelgood factor
5
Readers' rating
By Gavin Green
First Drives
11 June 2010 00:01
It’s finally here. The world’s first practical affordable electric production car that doesn’t look like it’s designed by a kid with a crayon and driven by Noddy. The Nissan Leaf may not be an exciting car. But it is an important one. If it sells – and Nissan CEO Carlos Ghosn is betting his company’s future on it – this may be a Mini/Model T moment. Game changers aren’t released very often.
The Leaf goes on sale early next year and, as long as David Cameron rubber-stamps Lord Mandelson’s grant, European production will come from Sunderland from 2013 (and from Japan until then). Unlike the G-Wiz and other similarly risible electric runabouts, this is not a ‘quadricycle’ that circumvents all safety rules (and common sense). It’s a proper car, meeting all Golf-sized hatchback safety expectations, seats five, and looks like a ‘proper’ car. Nissan purposefully made it look ‘normal’, hinting at unconventionality (note the rakish TGV like-nose) but not going too Dan Dare. This is a mass-produced Nissan, after all, and expected to have mass appeal.
It’s £28,350 – but that drops to £23,350 after the UK government grant. (Many European governments, as well as the US and Japan, are offering similar rebates.) That’s still a fair bit more than a same-size Golf or Focus. But when the much lower running costs – the electricity should cost about a fifth as much as petrol or diesel – are factored, the AA reckons you’ll get that extra money back in about three years. The Leaf is also exempt from London’s congestion charge and road tax, and there is zero company car tax for the first five years.
Top speed - 90mph - is some way behind petrol class rivals, although 0-60mph in 11.5 seconds is similar to a mainstream petrol Focus. But the Leaf isn’t designed for top-end motorway and A-road speed. Rather, it’s for urban and suburban use. Off the mark and from 20-40mph, the Leaf feels brisk. That’s a corollary of its meaty V6-like torque. What’s more, that torque is delivered almost instantly.
The Leaf accelerates with amazing smoothness and refinement. It’s quieter than a Rolls Phantom at low speed. Up to 15mph, the only discernible sound – more obvious to pedestrians than occupants – is a muted jet engine whirr, an artificial sound (conveyed by a nose-mounted speaker) designed to warn pedestrians of its imminence. Over 15 mph, it cuts out. Nissan figures tyre noise and engine whine provide enough aural warning after that.
This was the really pleasant surprise. The Leaf is no lightweight, at just over 1500 kg, mainly due to the batteries. Yet those new-generation lithium ion batteries are all cleverly mounted in the floor, under the seats. This keeps the main mass of the car nice and low.
The upshot is agile handling and little roll. The light electric motor up front helps. This is one front-drive car that doesn’t have the majority of its mass perched over its front axle. Turn-in is sharp, steering pleasingly linear and light, and overall agility is a notch or two better than the mid-size hatch norm. Mind you our test was on a billiard-smooth Japanese track. We’ll have to wait and see how it fares on Britain’s broken B-roads, but the signs are promising.
>> Click 'Next' below to read more of our Nissan Leaf first drive
Add your comment
Sign in You must be signed in to submit a comment.
Nissan Leaf (2010) electric prototype CAR review
Subject
Your comment
By submitting your comment, you agree to adhere to the CAR Magazine website Terms and Conditions
Cancel
You must be logged in to subscribe to a topic
Login or register now
PamelaS says
RE: Nissan Leaf (2010) electric car CAR review
Personally, I loving the idea of a good EV - great hit of instant performance from the low down torque, yes the price and weight is a bit high and the range a little short - both of these will improve with 2nd and 3rd generations - well done to Nissan for pushing EV's for the masses forward a step or two.
17 January 2011 16:26
PaulScott says
Hi All, good comments, but from the questions I saw, I think you'd benefit from some experience. I've been driving a production EV from Toyota for almost 8 years and 85,000 miles here in Santa Monica. There are a few hundred of us who were lucky enough to get one of the rare RAV4 EVs made in 2002 and 2003. To a person, we've all had amazing experiences. Virtually all these small SUVs have performed flawlessly with almost zero maintenance needed. According to a survey, about 50% of us use solar PV to generate the energy, so there is zero pollution, well-to-wheels. All of our money stays domestic, with most of it staying in our pockets to be spent locally, generating jobs here instead of in other countries. We seriously enjoy the pleasure of not giving any money to the oil companies. That really feels good. It also feels good to know that we aren't polluting our children's air. That's a big one. The cars are much quicker than the gas version, and quiet as a mouse. Consider how pleasant your neighborhoods will be when all the pollution and noise from internal combustion is gone. For more info on the coming EVs, please see www.pluginamerica.org. You're really going to love the EV. Get a test drive as soon as you can and you'll see why.
Hi All, good comments, but from the questions I saw, I think you'd benefit from some experience.
I've been driving a production EV from Toyota for almost 8 years and 85,000 miles here in Santa Monica. There are a few hundred of us who were lucky enough to get one of the rare RAV4 EVs made in 2002 and 2003. To a person, we've all had amazing experiences. Virtually all these small SUVs have performed flawlessly with almost zero maintenance needed. According to a survey, about 50% of us use solar PV to generate the energy, so there is zero pollution, well-to-wheels.
All of our money stays domestic, with most of it staying in our pockets to be spent locally, generating jobs here instead of in other countries.
We seriously enjoy the pleasure of not giving any money to the oil companies. That really feels good.
It also feels good to know that we aren't polluting our children's air. That's a big one.
The cars are much quicker than the gas version, and quiet as a mouse. Consider how pleasant your neighborhoods will be when all the pollution and noise from internal combustion is gone.
For more info on the coming EVs, please see www.pluginamerica.org. You're really going to love the EV. Get a test drive as soon as you can and you'll see why.
09 September 2010 08:13
Biram Desai says
Yes Brand0 and Timbo365, I do see what you are both saying - but hope not to bore everyone by restating that where, when, how, and why we use are cars is going to become increasingly important as the costs of running a petrol or diesel ICE will rise and electric vehicles are not a "one-stop-shop" solution. Economics and personal disposable income may require us to significantly re-consider all the aspects of our car usage - and I think this may be an interesting Car article though may be considered beyond the remit (ie to entertain as well as educate us!!)
15 June 2010 18:31
timbo65 says
Nice car, but way too expensive! Even with that discount it costs what I paid for my brand new 320i coupe last year, and I know what I'd rather be driving. And are those who pay in excess of £20k for cars that concerned about the long term savings. I dont buy into the big Co2 lie anyway and I think this car will sell to those who want to sit in their car, smugly thinking to themselves, 'I'm not poluting the planet'. Well I dont believe I am when I'm driving my petrol car! Even if the big pollution argument has some truth to it, which I'm sure it has, electric cars will have to be as cheap to buy as the equivalent petrol model before the masses will buy into it!
15 June 2010 14:27
Brand0 says
BIRAM - Interesting point, but on the other hand, in terms of sales, it's not to bad a strategy to target a class of car that sells a high number of units. The family hatchback is so popular that sniping even a small percentage should net decent sales. Of course, if this were a 1-Series, A/B-Class or A3 one could rest assured. If there are people out there who are prepared to spend £35k on a loaded 135i or RS3 (or Imprezza for that matter), surely there must be enough out there who'd spend money on Green tech, if that's what floats their boat.
15 June 2010 14:12
Upload stories, photos or videos direct to the site, or email newsdesk@carmagazine.co.uk.
Alternatively, call 01733 468 485 (+ 44 1733 468 485)
Seen a secret new car, fabulous exotic or have news we should publish? Then get in touch now.