Skip to content
Porsche models, news & reviews
4
Handling
Performance
Usability
5
Feelgood factor
3
Readers' rating
By Tim Pollard
First Drives
18 June 2009 13:00
You know a car is long awaited when it’s given an entire engine transplant before it’s even been launched. CAR first rode in the new Porsche Cayenne Hybrid back in July 2007. Two years later, it’s still not on sale and now it’s been transformed from a 3.6 V6 into the Cayenne S Hybrid toting Audi’s new 3.0-litre supercharged V6. And we’re promised that what you see here is exactly what you’ll be able to buy from next year.
We’ve driven Porsche’s new hybrid at a Bosch technology day ahead of the petrol-electric Cayenne’s launch in 2010. And don’t assume this is some nichey, low-volume sports SUV eco sop – what you see here is exactly what will underpin the new VW Touareg Hybrid and Porshce Panamera Hybrid as well – the entire engine, transmission and drivetrain will form the basis for all three petrol-electric vehicles.
Out goes the old VW VR6-related 3.6 V6, replaced by the silken, direct-injection 3.0-litre V6 that we’ve already come to admire in the new Audi S4. Worries before we even start it up? In our long-term test S4, we still mourn the loss of the V8 burble and are becoming worried the official consumption claims have gone equally AWOL.
Bosch has supplied the hybrid module and control unit, but not the battery packs (its own lithium ion battery joint venture with Samsung won’t produce results until 2011). The electric drivetrain sits between the V6 and the new, eight-speed auto transmission. A separate clutch between the engine and gearbox means that the Cayenne Hybrid can decouple the petrol engine entirely, running on either pure electric or corner-baiting petrol mode in full four-wheel drive. Other systems, such as the Lexus RX450h’s, effectively run the rear axle electrically.
Yep – this is the first time I’ve tested a petrol-electric car with a full torque converter auto instead of a CVT. You notice it the moment you step on board and start up. Pull away, and the Cayenne Hybrid offers conventional gearchanges even in full EV mode. It makes for a much more conventional ‘car-like’ experience (even thought that phrase annoys me – of course it’s a bloody car!) and you won’t miss that wildly unhinged CVT racket and soaring revs one jot.
It takes a while to adjust, because the Cayenne Hybrid then changes down when you brake, even when the engine is switched off and you’re coasting along in ‘sailing’ mode. But it’s entirely in keeping with the Porsche dynamic DNA and the gearchanges are slusher-slick. It’s a healthy blend of old and new, then – and with eight ratios, the Aisin auto box is biased towards changing up early. Seventh and eight are, needless to say, overdrives.
>> Click ‘Next’ to read how the Cayenne Hybrid fares on road
Add your comment
Sign in You must be signed in to submit a comment.
Porsche Cayenne S Hybrid (2010) CAR review
Subject
Your comment
By submitting your comment, you agree to adhere to the CAR Magazine website Terms and Conditions
Cancel
You must be logged in to subscribe to a topic
Login or register now
Carian says
RE: Porsche Cayenne S Hybrid (2010) CAR review
The interesting thing is they're not mentioning that by the time this hybrid is available for sale, the brand new Cayenne will have been introduced. So, in a sense, you could look at the announcement and development of the 'Cayenne Hybrid' on the current model as a testbed.
23 June 2009 17:56
comment8 says
kdolton - A cursory look at the results of the trans siberia rally show the field was made up of 70% Porsche Cayennes. 30% of those failed to make it to the finish. I think the race can be most kindly described as a vanity racing/marketing event. Perhaps the substantial VW DNA to be found in the Cayenne will elevate it from terrible reliability to a VW mediocre level.
23 June 2009 04:45
wittgenfrog says
This is yet another situation in which I find myself in the same camp, or at leat the same County as JB. Current hybrids seem to offer almost the worst of both worlds. They are always heavier than their deisel or petrol counterparts, they contain stacks of noxious hard-to-recycle chemicals, they offer no huge improvement in fuel consumption. When a company like Porsche hybridises a car as stupid and egocentric as the Cayenne all it acheives is to emphasise how devoid of intelligence and innovation it is. So this particular oversized housebrick of a peon to personal inadequacy uses (marginally) less fuel than some of its siblings. I'm not that impressed. Realistically, however, Porsche has never innovated. Their Road Cars started-out as re-skinned VWs and whilst they are great developers they aren't inventors. I suppose its unrealistic for me to expect them to start being original now.... Porsche are not that much worse than most other makers at present: a sucession of me-too overweight, overblown, over-engined dross fills the pages of "Car" every month. Its just really boring. I really hope that all the purveyors of these monstrosities are secretly working on something more interesting, otherwise they really are all doomed. What we petrolheads need is for someone to take some leadership here.
This is yet another situation in which I find myself in the same camp, or at leat the same County as JB. Current hybrids seem to offer almost the worst of both worlds. They are always heavier than their deisel or petrol counterparts, they contain stacks of noxious hard-to-recycle chemicals, they offer no huge improvement in fuel consumption.
When a company like Porsche hybridises a car as stupid and egocentric as the Cayenne all it acheives is to emphasise how devoid of intelligence and innovation it is. So this particular oversized housebrick of a peon to personal inadequacy uses (marginally) less fuel than some of its siblings. I'm not that impressed.
Realistically, however, Porsche has never innovated. Their Road Cars started-out as re-skinned VWs and whilst they are great developers they aren't inventors. I suppose its unrealistic for me to expect them to start being original now....
Porsche are not that much worse than most other makers at present: a sucession of me-too overweight, overblown, over-engined dross fills the pages of "Car" every month. Its just really boring. I really hope that all the purveyors of these monstrosities are secretly working on something more interesting, otherwise they really are all doomed.
What we petrolheads need is for someone to take some leadership here.
19 June 2009 12:49
kdolton says
Comment8, so, my ''Transsyberria-crushing reliability" is pure fantasy'. To back this up, you then refer, for some bizzare reason, to the reliability of an entirely different model. The article, and my comment, refer to the Cayenne. Last years Trans Syberia Rally results: 1st place: Porsche Cayenne 2nd place: Porsche Cayenne 3rd place: Porsche Cayenne 4th place: Porsche Cayenne Starting to get the picture? There were plenty of other entries from other manufacturers, but they knew when they entered the best they could do was compete for best-placed-that-wasn't-a-Cayenne, as a Cayenne had crushed all opposition the year before. And the year before that. For your information, the Cayennes taking part were more or less as they came out the box - the rules only allow minor mods from standard road cars, such as enlarged fuel tanks. Yes, Transsyberria-crushing they certainly are. And the hybrid, with its additional step-off torque, creamy smooth engine and significantly inproved range/consumption, along with 6.8 0-100kph time will surely be the ultimate real world Cayenne.
Comment8, so, my ''Transsyberria-crushing reliability" is pure fantasy'. To back this up, you then refer, for some bizzare reason, to the reliability of an entirely different model. The article, and my comment, refer to the Cayenne.
Last years Trans Syberia Rally results:
1st place: Porsche Cayenne
2nd place: Porsche Cayenne
3rd place: Porsche Cayenne
4th place: Porsche Cayenne
Starting to get the picture? There were plenty of other entries from other manufacturers, but they knew when they entered the best they could do was compete for best-placed-that-wasn't-a-Cayenne, as a Cayenne had crushed all opposition the year before. And the year before that. For your information, the Cayennes taking part were more or less as they came out the box - the rules only allow minor mods from standard road cars, such as enlarged fuel tanks.
Yes, Transsyberria-crushing they certainly are. And the hybrid, with its additional step-off torque, creamy smooth engine and significantly inproved range/consumption, along with 6.8 0-100kph time will surely be the ultimate real world Cayenne.
19 June 2009 09:44
JohnnyBimmer says
Well if Toyota and Hoinda hybrids weren't enough to convince you their drivers have no interest in motoring whatsoever then Porsches' ugly pig hits the movement from a different angle, they've also no taste! The Cayenne delivers the final nail in the hybrid coffin. Boring, fat, ugly and with no perceptable attribute anyone can find is no way to go through life (cue funeral music)...
19 June 2009 09:40
Upload stories, photos or videos direct to the site, or email newsdesk@carmagazine.co.uk.
Alternatively, call 01733 468 485 (+ 44 1733 468 485)
Seen a secret new car, fabulous exotic or have news we should publish? Then get in touch now.