Mercedes-AMG A45 S review: raising the bar

Published:31 July 2019

Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • At a glance
  • 5 out of 5
  • 5 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 5 out of 5

By Anthony ffrench-Constant

Contributing editor, architect, sentence constructor, amuse bouche

By Anthony ffrench-Constant

Contributing editor, architect, sentence constructor, amuse bouche

► Most powerful four-cylinder in world
► 4Matic+ rear diff adds multidisc clutch per wheel
► Prodigious grip, perfidious software 

So, with the Mercedes-AMG A35 already available for a mere £35,000 (plus ten grand’s worth of options, natch), what’s a Mercedes-AMG A45 S got to offer to justify a £15,000 hike in starting price (plus… etc.)?

Well, a different clutch of rivals for starters. Leaving the A35 to take on the likes of Honda’s Civic Type R and the evergreen Golf R, the price hike affording you an A45 S moves us smartly into Audi RS3 and BMW M2 territory, and beyond…

The A45 gets the AMG Panamerica grille

Other than that, there’s an infotainment system of enough complexity and software breadth to make you hoot with delight or howl at the moon, depending on what you buy a very fast hatchback for (which we’ll come to). 

Oh, yes, and attached to some extremely trick mechanical engineering in the undercarriage department, there’s also the world’s most powerful turbocharged four-cylinder engine in series production.

Tell us about the A45 S’ engine then? 

This sounds like the cue for the old Formula 1 technology plug – and it is. Indeed, along with other associated slaver-worthy stuff such as ‘motorsport derived’, ‘closed-deck construction’, ‘hand-mad’, ‘one man – one engine’, ‘NANOSLIDE-coated cylinder liners’ and ‘all-aluminium crankcase’.

This new unit shares the A 35’s 1991cc cubic capacity and transverse mounting but, other than that, precious little else – even having been installed 180 degrees the other way round for better ducting of both intake and exhaust air. Is that, I wonder, a tacit admission that the A 35’s unit is the wrong way round?

Here's that mighty, turbocharged four-cylinder

And how fast is it? 

Anyway, anything and everything under the bonnet has been meticulously, painstakingly fettled to the point of delivering 415bhp at 6750rpm and 368lb ft of torque at around 5000rpm. And when married to an eight-speed dual-clutch transmission and four-wheel drive, this translates into a quoted 0-62mph time of 3.9 seconds, and 167mph some way down the road.

The + tacked onto the all-wheel drive system’s 4MATIC nomenclature stands for a new rear axle differential boasting one multidisc clutch for each rear wheel. This means that not only is torque automatically shunted up to 50% fore and 100% aft, but also up to 100% from side to side astern.

The A45 has the usual Affalterbach styling

This cunning installation equips the A 45 with one more driving mode than lesser models – Drift. Unfortunately, Mercedes didn’t fancy letting their guests loose on the skid pan to sample this vomit-inducing accessory for themselves, so I can only report as an observer that it works well enough to empty your wallet of replacement 245/35 ZR 19s in no time flat.

So what’s it like when you are allowed to drive?

Somewhat marvellous, actually. You only really need two of the seven driving modes on offer; ‘Comfort’, for bumbling about, and ‘Sport +’ for hooning. In the former, every parameter from the frequency-selective shock absorbers to the throttle, gearbox and steering are slackened off to just a whisker short of bagginess, which is ideal for mulching about in urban mayhem.

But dial in the latter and everything mechanical sits up straight, clenches its stomach muscles and pays attention. The eight-speed dual clutch transmission remains appropriately oleaginous under paddle control, only occasionally delivering the hint of a head-nod nudge as you close on the rev limit in each gear.

Which, with increasingly relentless fervour, you will do, not only because there’s precious little torque on offer below 3000rpm (even in this up-and-at-’em drive mode), but also because, under pressure, this is one of the best sounding four-cylinder units around – an enthusiastically waspish exhaust note worth chasing, and all the requisite small arms fire you could wish for on overrun.

Mercedes AMG A45 grille

Imbued with a little extra heft, the steering is pleasingly meaty and ruthlessly accurate, communicating a whiff more about what’s going on under the front tyres than expected. And cornering is a guinea a minute…

With inner rear braking intervention tucking you into bends and optimum torque distribution chucking you out, the limits of twitch-free, lean-on-the-outer-rear-as-hard-as-you-like cornering seem constantly just out of reach. Push harder, and harder, and harder, and those clever mechanicals just go ‘Oh, OK’, allowing you back on the throttle absurdly, and increasingly, early as faith in grunt-allied grip grows.

Smooth Spanish tarmac makes a poor jury when it comes to ride quality adjudication, so all that can be reported at this stage is that the ride is acceptably pliant in bumbling mode, toughening with every rung of the drive mode ladder climbed. The extent to which fillings are threatened on our hopeless UK roads remains to be seen…

And the A45 S interior?

Much like an exterior design which mixes standard A-Class fayre with the face of a man reaching his limits in a NASA centrifuge, a mixed bag.

Despite protestations from some that the A 35’s driver’s seat is set too high, I find the driving position in the A 45 S to be absolutely fine. The helm could adjust a tad further south, but the seat’s comfortable and supportive, and all ergonomics first class. And there’s adequate room for a brace of six-footers in the back, though in CLA guise headroom is distinctly limited.

Twin 10.25-inch screens presented as a high-gloss pizza chef’s paddle chopped into the dash-top in lieu of a properly cowled instrument binnacle are all very well, and do boast excellent graphics. But they lay the foundations for a software quagmire of Glastonbury-esque platform and content complexity. 

The A45 S interior

Control systems in triplicate may be reassuring aboard an Airbus, but give off a strong whiff of overkill to those flying at ground level. And over and above the inevitable drive mode and undercarriage selection systems, the surfing of screen after screen after screen unearths the endlessly adjustable parameters of myriad Stuff You Didn’t Know You Needed.

Apparently, the Chinese love this sort of thing, but those of us who have no time to spare for glancing at G-force metres and stopwatches when pressing on find it, at best a distraction, and, at worst – when the absence of a simple button means menu surfing merely to disengage the loathsome and steering-corrupting lane keeping assistant every time you start the car – increasingly irksome.

Choose your flavour

Is the CLA 45 a very different kettle of fish?

Far from it. But for a few nominal differences, the Coupe, Light, A-Class 45 S is an identical twin. Its body shape means the CLA 45 S can wear a wider front and rear track, by 8mm and 27mm respectively, 19-inch wheels that are half an inch wider front and back, and commensurately larger 255/35 ZR 19 tyres than the hatchback’s 245s. Everything else mechanical is identical; differences in bodyshell and 50kg extra in the kerb weight stakes making the CLA 0.1 of a second slower to 62mph than the A.

Those owning their own racing booties are destined to tell you that minimally wider track and rubber award the baby saloon a whisker greater handling prowess than the hatchback, but after a day and half pressing on, all I’m prepared to concede is that the CLA makes the same enthralling assortment of noises off, the addition of a boot simply delivering them from what sounds like farther off.

Mercedes-AMG A45 S: verdict

With starting prices estimated at £50,000 for the hatch and £52,000 for the saloon, the A 45 S is not a cheap offering. Unlike its predecessor, however, it does at least seem worth it; at least for the fabulous engineering and terrific dynamics, if not the supercilious software.

More Mercedes-Benz reviews by CAR magazine


Price when new: £50,000
On sale in the UK: August 2019
Engine: 1991cc, 16v turbo petrol four-cylinder, 415bhp @ 6750rpm, 368lb ft @ 5000-5250rpm
Transmission: 8-speed twin-clutch auto with paddle shift, all-wheel drive
Performance: 3.9 sec 0-62mph (4.0 CLA 45 S), 167mph top speed, 34.0mpg (34.9mpg CLA 45 S), 189g/km CO2 (186g/km CLA 45 S)
Weight / material: 1550kg (1600kg CLA 45 S) (DIN), 1625kg (1675kg CLA 45 S) (EU
Dimensions (length/width/height in mm): 4445/1850/1412 (4693/1857/1413 CLA 45 S)

Photo Gallery

  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S
  • Mercedes-AMG A45 S

By Anthony ffrench-Constant

Contributing editor, architect, sentence constructor, amuse bouche