Skip to content
Citroen models, news & reviews
3
Handling
Performance
Usability
Feelgood factor
Readers' rating
4
By Anthony ffrench-Constant
First Drives
19 October 2009 15:44
The new Citroen C3 (2009) wades into a fizzed-up supermini marketplace. With the likes of the Ford Fiesta and VW’s new Polo raising the bar to Sergei Bubka heights in the B segment of late, anything not now boasting debutante levels of deportment and style is going to have to rely on a price tag of little more than a bag of marbles and a previously owned Fisherman’s Friend to get so much as a sniff of the action.
This, of course, has always been Citroen’s forte; the dumpy little C3 relentlessly discounted to the point of distraction from its diverse shortcomings. So - in the context of a new model which boasts a significant stride forward in the style, quality and dynamic stakes whilst now matching the price of top end rivals - it’ll be interesting to see if the thriftier B segment buyers that Citroen traditional attracts will be prepared to foot the bill.
Well, the outgoing model had all the appeal of a pre-lanced boil, so almost any treatment would be a step in the right direction. The new-for-2009 C3 is far better looking, even if we have yet to see it without that giant, peel-back windscreen which will be a standard fit on most posher models in the range.
First seen on Vauxhall’s Panorama, I’ve never been sold on the glass toboggan, simply because the moment the glazing outside wiper coverage gets dirty you’re merely dealing with acres of opaque glass. Not to mention the need for sun visors in Britain for so much of the year…But the interior is little short of a dramatic improvement. This is the dashboard architecture of the forthcoming DS3, and build quality, fit and finishes have all taken a stout hike uphill. Everything looks good, and works well, even if the fiddly-buttoned screen control panel should have found itself above the big-buttoned, set-and-forget air-con dials on the centre console.
The driving position’s fine, though the seat is considerably harder than that of the C3 Picasso. However, sitting behind yourself in the back isn’t such a pleasure, and I’m surprised that Citroen has sacrificed rear seat legroom in the interests of crowing over class-leading luggage space. And finding a sawn-off steering wheel in a C3 smacks worryingly of dynamic pretensions that could severely damage the Citroen USP, ride comfort.
Well, mercifully, despite the fact that the new C3 is significantly more agile than its predecessor, the Macpherson front and torsion beam rear undercarriage still gives a pleasingly supple ride. It’ll never challenge a Fiesta thrown down a boisterous B-road, but far better that than destroy straight line comfort.
The occasional road racket all too clearly transmitted to the cabin from poorer surfaces is a touch baffling, though, since Citroen claims to have tripled the sound insulation on the car. Then again, they also say that this car is no heavier than its predecessor… Something, somewhere, doesn’t quite add up. It’ll be interesting to see how the C3 copes with our dreadful roads.
Add your comment
Sign in You must be signed in to submit a comment.
Citroen C3 1.6 HDi (2009) CAR review
Subject
Your comment
By submitting your comment, you agree to adhere to the CAR Magazine website Terms and Conditions
Cancel
You must be logged in to subscribe to a topic
Login or register now
georgios1976 says
RE: Citroen C3 1.6 HDi (2009) CAR review
The original C3 looked good, had excellent diesel engines, was a mediocre drive, badly packaged and had awfully bad build quality in the cabin. The new model improves on most areas, the cabin in particular looks stunning, although packaging still seems bad for a car nearly 4m long, if I am to believe Anthony ffrench-Constant. I can hardly understand Citroen's decision to price this car so optimistically. I am sure that within 6 months from going on sale, four-figure discounts will be available. Seems like a good car in a class of excellence, as witnessed by cars like Fiesta, Polo, Clio, 207, Punto and Corsa.
26 October 2009 19:29
KOLOtweets says
"Well, the outgoing model had all the appeal of a pre-lanced boil" .....but this is a clear evolution of it. I'm getting less and less impressed with CAR, it's getting too lazy; spelling mistakes, copying press releases instead of making an opinion, heavily relying on second or third hand sources for stories. Having said that, this article isn't too bad. The C3 is a huge leap forward in cabin design even if the exterior is close to the original. But it's flying too close with the DS3, why pay a premium for less doors and similar kit? Especially as the 'standard' C is rather good.
"Well, the outgoing model had all the appeal of a pre-lanced boil"
.....but this is a clear evolution of it.
I'm getting less and less impressed with CAR, it's getting too lazy; spelling mistakes, copying press releases instead of making an opinion, heavily relying on second or third hand sources for stories.
Having said that, this article isn't too bad.
The C3 is a huge leap forward in cabin design even if the exterior is close to the original.
But it's flying too close with the DS3, why pay a premium for less doors and similar kit?
Especially as the 'standard' C is rather good.
22 October 2009 16:19
Johann says
Lovely. Drive the same engined model twice and then do a "balanced" review on a car??! Gosh. And Mr f-C can't even spel Citroën correctly to boot. Not difficult to look up how to type that little ë now is it? (I'll help: on a PC you hold the ALT key and type 137 at the same time). Please remember for next time. Back to the car. I sat in various C3's at the Frankfurt Motor show and was very impressed. Love the panoramic roof and yes it does have the exact same sliding rollerblind machanism with sunvisors in the leading edge as the Astra (to answer one commenter's question). What surprised me most though was the quality of the interior. It looked great, felt great and had a real class-above-ness about it. It really amplified the creaks in the C6 interior on display nearby.
Lovely. Drive the same engined model twice and then do a "balanced" review on a car??! Gosh. And Mr f-C can't even spel Citroën correctly to boot. Not difficult to look up how to type that little ë now is it? (I'll help: on a PC you hold the ALT key and type 137 at the same time). Please remember for next time.
Back to the car. I sat in various C3's at the Frankfurt Motor show and was very impressed. Love the panoramic roof and yes it does have the exact same sliding rollerblind machanism with sunvisors in the leading edge as the Astra (to answer one commenter's question). What surprised me most though was the quality of the interior. It looked great, felt great and had a real class-above-ness about it. It really amplified the creaks in the C6 interior on display nearby.
21 October 2009 14:30
Vilagos says
I like this C3, the shape, the interior - charming color on the promo pics, too. OK, it's not a full four seater. Not death in a city car, which need to carry stuff The panornama windshield is also a good concept for a city car. It's fun to be able to look up at all the buildings, feels more like walking around than being cooped up in a small rolling box. Presumably, there's a sunshade built in, like in a Porsche Targa or Smart. Sun visors must be a legal requirement, though I don't see any in the pics. As for the Author's prose, which appears to have drawn as much comment as the test car, it's an excellent reminder to try the car yourself if it appeals to you, rather than slavishly follow the recommendations of a magazine. You have to live with it, they get a new one every week!
I like this C3, the shape, the interior - charming color on the promo pics, too. OK, it's not a full four seater. Not death in a city car, which need to carry stuff
The panornama windshield is also a good concept for a city car. It's fun to be able to look up at all the buildings, feels more like walking around than being cooped up in a small rolling box. Presumably, there's a sunshade built in, like in a Porsche Targa or Smart. Sun visors must be a legal requirement, though I don't see any in the pics.
As for the Author's prose, which appears to have drawn as much comment as the test car, it's an excellent reminder to try the car yourself if it appeals to you, rather than slavishly follow the recommendations of a magazine. You have to live with it, they get a new one every week!
20 October 2009 19:11
Archibold says
RE: Citroen C3 1.6 HDi 90hp Exclusive CAR review
Torsion beam rear axle, does that mean the ride is mediocre compared to a 205 or an AX, shame they can't fit independant suspension all round like they did thirty years ago, all in all this article seems rather shallow, Peugeot need to stop looking at offering crayon book developments (DS3/C3) and get some engineers back in the firm.
20 October 2009 10:45
Upload stories, photos or videos direct to the site, or email newsdesk@carmagazine.co.uk.
Alternatively, call 01733 468 485 (+ 44 1733 468 485)
Seen a secret new car, fabulous exotic or have news we should publish? Then get in touch now.