Used car stars 2016: 208 GTi vs Swift Sport vs Focus ST, CAR+ June 2016 | CAR Magazine

Used car stars 2016: 208 GTi vs Swift Sport vs Focus ST, CAR+ June 2016

Published: 01 May 2016 Updated: 10 June 2016

► Three affordable hot hatches compared
► Peugeot takes on Suzuki and Ford 
► Fun FWD hatches for upwards of £4k 

You could argue that we’re in a golden age of hot hatches right now. The spread is wide and the going is good, with few genuine duffers. Take this trio, of Suzuki Swift Sport, Peugeot 208 GTi and Ford Focus ST; with power outputs ranging from around 134bhp to 247bhp and pricing from £4k, there’s something here for everybody.

Suzuki Swift Sport (2006-on) – from £4k! 

The Swift Sport is more korma than jalfrezi but it’s got personality to burn and one of those rarest of commodities in 2016: a rev-hungry naturally-aspirated petrol engine. That £4k price will only buy you a previous generation, 2006-2012 example (in fact, you can get one for half that, if you’re prepared to gamble on it having been thrashed) but since the formula and the foundations are largely the same, both this and the car from 2012 hit the same sweet spot. Few cars deliver so fully on their potential, let alone from a position of such modesty. Wind one of these up and you’ll have a grin a mile wide.

Significant differences between the two generations are the extra 50mm in the Mk2 Sport’s wheelbase, helping refine the chassis, the addition of a sixth gear ratio for less frenetic cruising, and an uprated 1.6-litre four-pot that swells power from 123bhp to 134bhp. You get fewer trim rattles in the newer car, too, though that might just be age related. As such, the Mk1 is rawer, firmer, less good at long journeys; the Mk2 more grown up but a smidge less sharp. Both require strict adherence to the servicing regime, which includes shorter intervals than you might expect; gearboxes can be troublesome if abused.

Peugeot 208 GTi (2013-on) – from £10k!

If there’s a sign that Peugeot has finally turned a corner it’s the 208 GTi. Right from launch in 2013, it was clear the magic was back – if not quite so much of the lift-off oversteer. For while the Pug’s 197bhp 1.6-litre turbo out-muscles the Fiesta ST’s 180bhp equivalent on paper, it’s no disservice to say the chassis has been set-up with less of an edge than the Ford’s, especially since the greater compliance that comes along with this makes the Peugeot much easier to live with day-to-day.

That’s also not to say it’s too much of a softy – stacks of grip and 203lb ft of torque at just 1700rpm makes short work of any road. And at under £10k for a 20,000-mile example, the Pug is a bargain. And if you can find 50% more you’ll even bag a limited run 30th Edition, with more power (205bhp), Brembo brakes and track-ready handling. This spec was incorporated into the standard model range as the 208 GTi by Peugeot Sport after the 2015 facelift. 

Ford Focus ST (2012-on) – save £11k! 

Looking for something a little more, er, challenging? Look no further than a lightly-used Ford Focus ST. The first time you light up the Mk3 Focus ST’s front wheels out of a roundabout and the steering wheel starts writhing in your hands like a python having a panic attack, you’ll find yourself wishing you hadn’t skimped on the arm curls at the gym. This fast Ford can be a handful, make no mistake, but the brutish way it shoves 247bhp through its front tyres is very much part of the charm (though perhaps ‘charm’ won’t be the word you’ll use when you find yourself at Kwikfit. Again). And while it hasn’t quite the all-round class and capability of the Golf GTI, it’s more powerful (Ford’s quoted figure is decidedly conservative in our humble opinion) and exceptional value for money: prices for pre-facelift cars start at under £12k.

Post-facelift, the ST got prettier, received updated suspension settings for a smoother ride and gained a 182bhp diesel engine variant – with still more torque, this offers even more torque-steer, so we’d stick with the petrol unless you really need the economy. The estate is worth seeking out, though; dynamically there’s little compromise, but expect to drop at least a grand more to accommodate your luggage in such extravagant luxury. 4 

Peugeot 208 GTi

From £10k (£22,365 new)

1.6-litre turbo 4-cyl, 197bhp, 6.8sec 0-62mph, 144mph

Suzuki Swift Sport

From £4k (£14,499 new)

1.6-litre 4-cyl, 134bhp, 8.7sec 0-62mph, 121mph

Ford Focus ST

From £13k (£23,850 new)

2.0-litre turbo 4-cyl, 247bhp, 6.5sec 0-62mph, 154mph

Cars we found

Suzuki Swift Sport 

Silver, 41,000 miles, sports seats, one owner from new, full service history, £6949

Peugeot 208 GTi 

White, 22,763 miles, dual-zone climate control, DAB, bluetooth, half leather, cruise control and speed limiter, £9995

Ford Focus ST-2 

White, 26,235 miles, part-leather Recaro interior, Ford SYNC, DAB, bluetooth, USB, 15-month warranty, 12 months AA cover, £13,876 

Buying intel 

Suzuki Swift Sport

> 2006-2012 version has 124bhp; 2012 onwards version has 134bhp. Both powered by a 16v 1.6
> Six-speed gearbox (from 2012) makes for more relaxed cruising and the first five ratios remain closely stacked; both ’boxes benefit from regular oil changes – failures have been reported
> Service intervals are short at 9000 miles; make sure they’ve been met
> Tappets are not hydraulic, so require manual adjustment

Peugeot 208 GTi

> Revised late 2015 with a mild facelift and the addition of the more powerful GTi by Peugeot Sport variant (same specification as limited 30th Edition), a much more focused variant that trades some of the GTi’s everyday appeal for better track performance
> Issues include engine failure, misfires, loose fitting trim and poorly aligned panels
> Find a good one and they’re great, but choose wisely…

Ford Focus ST

> Launched in 2012 and revised in early 2015 with new looks and the introduction of a diesel model, priced the same as the petrol
> Later cars have recalibrated steering and suspension changes for a sharper drive; torque-steer remains a constant menace, despite torque vectoring electronics update
> Fuel economy not a strong point
> Turning circle so poor tight parking can take weeks…

Used car stars 2016 continued…

Used car stars 2016: save £35k on a BMW i8, plus 11 other used car bargains
Used car stars 2016: Peugeot RCZ-R vs Audi S5

Used car stars 2016: Jaguar F-type vs Porsche Boxster S
Used car stars 2016: Mercedes S-class vs Lexus GS
Used car stars 2016: VW Tiguan
Used car stars 2016: Ferrari 458 Italia

Read more from the June 2016 issue of CAR magazine