Used car stars 2016: Mercedes S-class vs Lexus GS, CAR+ June 2016 | CAR Magazine

Used car stars 2016: Mercedes S-class vs Lexus GS, CAR+ June 2016

Published: 01 May 2016 Updated: 10 June 2016

► Hybrid Lexus or diesel Mercedes?
► Pick up either for around £25k
► Part four of our used car stars

Mercedes S-class (2006-2013) Save £39k!  

So you’re looking for a little luxury? How about a lot, in the form of the previous generation Mercedes S-class, which could be on your drive for less than the price of a new 3-series, or the current Lexus GS450h, which delivers hybrid karma, 155mph performance and an interior so nice you’ll be asking to work from your car.

Just think: you might be perfectly happy with a 320d, but might you not be happier still in the biggest Benz for considerably less money? (Even though some of the savings are almosy certainly best put aside for the day Something Significant goes wrong…). For the W221 (Mercedes’ official designation for the 2006-2013 S-class) the Stuttgart limo company had a point to prove. The preceding W220 might have looked every inch the presidential express, but they all too quickly garnered a reputation for slightly shoddy build, troublesome Airmatic air suspension and, incredibly, rust.

Mercedes threw everything at this replacement model, cranking up the tech, elongating the dimensions and whacking on a set of rear arches that look suspiciously like they were originally destined for a Mk1 Ford Escort rally car – instant differentiation from the ancestor, even if the Airmatic remains a point of concern…

The W221 isn’t as achingly high-tech as the succeeding W222, but there were myriad toys, including one of the very first autonomous braking systems and night vision on the options list. Available in standard and long-wheelbase versions, the most sensible engine choice is the 3.0-litre V6 turbodiesel – but if you want an exotic cylinder count and aren’t too proud to support your local petrol station there’s always the S600 biturbo V12, or the AMG models.

A facelift in 2009 tweaked the dynamics, increased the efficiency and turbocharged the toy count, but visually the differences are nothing a private plate won’t dissemble. The interior hasn’t aged especially well, but ride and refinement remain first rate; if they aren’t you’d best establish exactly why before handing over the hard earned.

Mercedes S-class

From £23k (£61,940 in 2010)

3.0-litre turbodiesel V6, 255bhp, 7.1sec 0-62mph, 155mph

Cars we found

2012 Mercedes-Benz S350L CDI White, 49,000 miles, full history, £23,975

Buying intel

> Uneven ride height, noisy adjustment and hissing on switch-off indicate Airmatic issues
> Broken engine and transmission mounts cause vibration
> Later 7G-tronic autos smoother (all transmissions should be silent)

Lexus GS450h (2012-on) From £24k! 

On sale in the UK from 2012, the L10 Lexus GS450h launched alongside a non-hybrid 2.5-litre petrol V6 badged GS250, subsequently ousted by the hybrid GS300h 2.5-litre four-pot. But the full-fat GS450h is definitely the one you want; amping a 3.5-litre V6 with an electric motor to achieve 338bhp, 0-62mph in 5.9sec and the aforementioned 155mph top speed, this is a marvellously leftfield executive chariot that doesn’t demand much compromise over the predictable Germans. Although to be clear, even with all that electric motor assistance you shouldn’t expect fuel economy to match European diesels.

The big ‘spindle’ grille – made even more outstanding during last year’s facelift, pictured here – makes this one of the first Lexi to show signs of an actual personality; the aggressively addendaed F-Sport spec might even be considered brooding. Confirming this newfound strength of character, F-Sport also features adaptive variable suspension (AVS), 19-inch alloys and rear-wheel steering as standard for a satisfyingly crisp driving experience.

Prefer a more laid-back approach? Then try the fully-loaded Premier, which trades the 19s and rear-wheel steering for 18s and the fantastic Mark Levinson hi-fi. There was a lesser, non-AVS Luxury GS450h at first as well; all got sat-nav as standard, although the awkward remote touch controller takes some adjustment. Interior quality is almost unimpeachable, with billet metal accents and beautiful attention to detail, while reliability is every bit as good as Lexus’s reputation would suggest.

Lexus GS450h

From £24k (£49,995 new)

3.5-litre V6 with e-motor, 338bhp, 5.9sec 0-62mph, 155mph

Cars we found

2012 Lexus GS450h Premier Grey, 16,486 miles, Adaptive Variable Suspension, Mark Levinson stereo system, 18-way electric front seats, £25,975

Buying intel

> Wailing Constantly Variable Transmission isn’t to everyone’s taste, but you learn to live with it
> Lexus regular tops driver satisfaction surveys for quality, reliability and dealer service, and this is borne out by next to no reported issues

Used car stars 2016 continued…

Used car stars 2016: save £35k on a BMW i8, plus 11 other used car bargains
Used car stars 2016: Peugeot RCZ-R vs Audi S5
Used car stars 2016: Jaguar F-type vs Porsche Boxster S
Used car stars 2016: VW Tiguan
Used car stars 2016: 208 GTi vs Swift Sport vs Focus ST
Used car stars 2016: Ferrari 458 Italia

Read more from the June 2016 issue of CAR magazine